Center for the Defence of the Individual - HCJ 1630/16 - Masudi et al. v. Commander of IDF Forces in the West Bank Judgment
التحديثات HE wheel chair icon
Display File
Judgment | Judgment / Supreme Court | 23.03.2016
HCJ 1630/16 - Masudi et al. v. Commander of IDF Forces in the West Bank Judgment

Rejection of HaMoked's petition against the state's intention to destroy, in the Qalandiya Refugee Camp, the family home of the assailant in a stabbing attack in the Cave of the Patriarchs in December 2015. The Court rules by majority that it "cannot be avoided in this case that there are no grounds for interference, in light of precedent in its current form". In a dissenting opinion, Justice Mazuz states the petition should be accepted and the demolition order revoked, and reiterates his opinion that punitive home demolitions give rise to a number of difficult legal questions. He further joins Justice Vogelman's call, rejecting the petition, "to re-examine, in an expanded panel, issues regarding the enactment of Regulation 119", which provides the legal authority for punitive home demolitions.

Updates

HCJ rejects motion for further hearing on punitive house demolitions: “This is not the appropriate case for considering further review of the issues of principle relating to the use of Regulation 119 before an expanded panel of this Court”, ruled President Naor
31.03.2016
Read more
HaMoked to HCJ in motion for further hearing on punitive house demolitions: “Six justices of the Honorable Court believe themselves bound by case law… and are uncomfortable with this position”
30.03.2016
Read more
HaMoked to the HCJ on the issue of legality of punitive demolition: the time is ripe for a discussion of the principle issues before an expanded panel, in view of the fact that six of the justices are in favour of revisiting the prevailing case law
27.03.2016
Read more
HCJ majority approved another punitive demolition in Hebron: but two of the justices were in favor of revising the core issues in an expanded panel
23.03.2016
Read more

Related documents

array(7) { [0]=> array(5) { ["di_name"]=> string(13) "Documents3139" ["related_di_name"]=> string(13) "Documents3149" ["title"]=> string(83) "HCJFH 2624/16 - Masudi et al. v. Commander of IDF Forces in the West Bank Decision" ["documentDate"]=> string(19) "2016-03-31 00:00:00" ["type_di_name"]=> string(18) "Document Types1000" } [1]=> array(5) { ["di_name"]=> string(13) "Documents3139" ["related_di_name"]=> string(11) "Updates1697" ["title"]=> string(266) "HCJ rejects motion for further hearing on punitive house demolitions: “This is not the appropriate case for considering further review of the issues of principle relating to the use of Regulation 119 before an expanded panel of this Court”, ruled President Naor " ["documentDate"]=> string(19) "2016-03-31 00:00:00" ["type_di_name"]=> string(7) "updates" } [2]=> array(5) { ["di_name"]=> string(13) "Documents3139" ["related_di_name"]=> string(13) "Documents3148" ["title"]=> string(136) "HCJFH 2624/16 - Masudi et al. v. Commander of IDF Forces in the West Bank Request for Further Hearing and Request for an Interim Order " ["documentDate"]=> string(19) "2016-03-30 00:00:00" ["type_di_name"]=> string(5) "03_22" } [3]=> array(5) { ["di_name"]=> string(13) "Documents3139" ["related_di_name"]=> string(11) "Updates1696" ["title"]=> string(198) "HaMoked to HCJ in motion for further hearing on punitive house demolitions: “Six justices of the Honorable Court believe themselves bound by case law… and are uncomfortable with this position”" ["documentDate"]=> string(19) "2016-03-30 00:00:00" ["type_di_name"]=> string(7) "updates" } [4]=> array(5) { ["di_name"]=> string(13) "Documents3139" ["related_di_name"]=> string(11) "Updates1688" ["title"]=> string(248) "HaMoked to the HCJ on the issue of legality of punitive demolition: the time is ripe for a discussion of the principle issues before an expanded panel, in view of the fact that six of the justices are in favour of revisiting the prevailing case law" ["documentDate"]=> string(19) "2016-03-27 00:00:00" ["type_di_name"]=> string(7) "updates" } [5]=> array(5) { ["di_name"]=> string(13) "Documents3139" ["related_di_name"]=> string(11) "Updates1690" ["title"]=> string(147) "HCJ majority approved another punitive demolition in Hebron: but two of the justices were in favor of revising the core issues in an expanded panel" ["documentDate"]=> string(19) "2016-03-23 00:00:00" ["type_di_name"]=> string(7) "updates" } [6]=> array(5) { ["di_name"]=> string(13) "Documents3139" ["related_di_name"]=> string(13) "Documents3087" ["title"]=> string(114) "HCJ 1630/16 - Masudi et al. v. Commander of IDF Forces in the West Bank Petition for Order Nisi and Interim Order " ["documentDate"]=> string(19) "2016-02-28 00:00:00" ["type_di_name"]=> string(5) "03_22" } }
HCJFH 2624/16 - Masudi et al. v. Commander of IDF Forces in the West Bank Decision
31.03.2016 | החלטה
Read more
array(7) { [0]=> array(5) { ["di_name"]=> string(13) "Documents3139" ["related_di_name"]=> string(13) "Documents3149" ["title"]=> string(83) "HCJFH 2624/16 - Masudi et al. v. Commander of IDF Forces in the West Bank Decision" ["documentDate"]=> string(19) "2016-03-31 00:00:00" ["type_di_name"]=> string(18) "Document Types1000" } [1]=> array(5) { ["di_name"]=> string(13) "Documents3139" ["related_di_name"]=> string(11) "Updates1697" ["title"]=> string(266) "HCJ rejects motion for further hearing on punitive house demolitions: “This is not the appropriate case for considering further review of the issues of principle relating to the use of Regulation 119 before an expanded panel of this Court”, ruled President Naor " ["documentDate"]=> string(19) "2016-03-31 00:00:00" ["type_di_name"]=> string(7) "updates" } [2]=> array(5) { ["di_name"]=> string(13) "Documents3139" ["related_di_name"]=> string(13) "Documents3148" ["title"]=> string(136) "HCJFH 2624/16 - Masudi et al. v. Commander of IDF Forces in the West Bank Request for Further Hearing and Request for an Interim Order " ["documentDate"]=> string(19) "2016-03-30 00:00:00" ["type_di_name"]=> string(5) "03_22" } [3]=> array(5) { ["di_name"]=> string(13) "Documents3139" ["related_di_name"]=> string(11) "Updates1696" ["title"]=> string(198) "HaMoked to HCJ in motion for further hearing on punitive house demolitions: “Six justices of the Honorable Court believe themselves bound by case law… and are uncomfortable with this position”" ["documentDate"]=> string(19) "2016-03-30 00:00:00" ["type_di_name"]=> string(7) "updates" } [4]=> array(5) { ["di_name"]=> string(13) "Documents3139" ["related_di_name"]=> string(11) "Updates1688" ["title"]=> string(248) "HaMoked to the HCJ on the issue of legality of punitive demolition: the time is ripe for a discussion of the principle issues before an expanded panel, in view of the fact that six of the justices are in favour of revisiting the prevailing case law" ["documentDate"]=> string(19) "2016-03-27 00:00:00" ["type_di_name"]=> string(7) "updates" } [5]=> array(5) { ["di_name"]=> string(13) "Documents3139" ["related_di_name"]=> string(11) "Updates1690" ["title"]=> string(147) "HCJ majority approved another punitive demolition in Hebron: but two of the justices were in favor of revising the core issues in an expanded panel" ["documentDate"]=> string(19) "2016-03-23 00:00:00" ["type_di_name"]=> string(7) "updates" } [6]=> array(5) { ["di_name"]=> string(13) "Documents3139" ["related_di_name"]=> string(13) "Documents3087" ["title"]=> string(114) "HCJ 1630/16 - Masudi et al. v. Commander of IDF Forces in the West Bank Petition for Order Nisi and Interim Order " ["documentDate"]=> string(19) "2016-02-28 00:00:00" ["type_di_name"]=> string(5) "03_22" } } array(7) { [0]=> array(5) { ["di_name"]=> string(13) "Documents3139" ["related_di_name"]=> string(13) "Documents3149" ["title"]=> string(83) "HCJFH 2624/16 - Masudi et al. v. Commander of IDF Forces in the West Bank Decision" ["documentDate"]=> string(19) "2016-03-31 00:00:00" ["type_di_name"]=> string(18) "Document Types1000" } [1]=> array(5) { ["di_name"]=> string(13) "Documents3139" ["related_di_name"]=> string(11) "Updates1697" ["title"]=> string(266) "HCJ rejects motion for further hearing on punitive house demolitions: “This is not the appropriate case for considering further review of the issues of principle relating to the use of Regulation 119 before an expanded panel of this Court”, ruled President Naor " ["documentDate"]=> string(19) "2016-03-31 00:00:00" ["type_di_name"]=> string(7) "updates" } [2]=> array(5) { ["di_name"]=> string(13) "Documents3139" ["related_di_name"]=> string(13) "Documents3148" ["title"]=> string(136) "HCJFH 2624/16 - Masudi et al. v. Commander of IDF Forces in the West Bank Request for Further Hearing and Request for an Interim Order " ["documentDate"]=> string(19) "2016-03-30 00:00:00" ["type_di_name"]=> string(5) "03_22" } [3]=> array(5) { ["di_name"]=> string(13) "Documents3139" ["related_di_name"]=> string(11) "Updates1696" ["title"]=> string(198) "HaMoked to HCJ in motion for further hearing on punitive house demolitions: “Six justices of the Honorable Court believe themselves bound by case law… and are uncomfortable with this position”" ["documentDate"]=> string(19) "2016-03-30 00:00:00" ["type_di_name"]=> string(7) "updates" } [4]=> array(5) { ["di_name"]=> string(13) "Documents3139" ["related_di_name"]=> string(11) "Updates1688" ["title"]=> string(248) "HaMoked to the HCJ on the issue of legality of punitive demolition: the time is ripe for a discussion of the principle issues before an expanded panel, in view of the fact that six of the justices are in favour of revisiting the prevailing case law" ["documentDate"]=> string(19) "2016-03-27 00:00:00" ["type_di_name"]=> string(7) "updates" } [5]=> array(5) { ["di_name"]=> string(13) "Documents3139" ["related_di_name"]=> string(11) "Updates1690" ["title"]=> string(147) "HCJ majority approved another punitive demolition in Hebron: but two of the justices were in favor of revising the core issues in an expanded panel" ["documentDate"]=> string(19) "2016-03-23 00:00:00" ["type_di_name"]=> string(7) "updates" } [6]=> array(5) { ["di_name"]=> string(13) "Documents3139" ["related_di_name"]=> string(13) "Documents3087" ["title"]=> string(114) "HCJ 1630/16 - Masudi et al. v. Commander of IDF Forces in the West Bank Petition for Order Nisi and Interim Order " ["documentDate"]=> string(19) "2016-02-28 00:00:00" ["type_di_name"]=> string(5) "03_22" } }
HCJFH 2624/16 - Masudi et al. v. Commander of IDF Forces in the West Bank Request for Further Hearing and Request for an Interim Order
30.03.2016 | עתירה לבג"ץ
Read more
array(7) { [0]=> array(5) { ["di_name"]=> string(13) "Documents3139" ["related_di_name"]=> string(13) "Documents3149" ["title"]=> string(83) "HCJFH 2624/16 - Masudi et al. v. Commander of IDF Forces in the West Bank Decision" ["documentDate"]=> string(19) "2016-03-31 00:00:00" ["type_di_name"]=> string(18) "Document Types1000" } [1]=> array(5) { ["di_name"]=> string(13) "Documents3139" ["related_di_name"]=> string(11) "Updates1697" ["title"]=> string(266) "HCJ rejects motion for further hearing on punitive house demolitions: “This is not the appropriate case for considering further review of the issues of principle relating to the use of Regulation 119 before an expanded panel of this Court”, ruled President Naor " ["documentDate"]=> string(19) "2016-03-31 00:00:00" ["type_di_name"]=> string(7) "updates" } [2]=> array(5) { ["di_name"]=> string(13) "Documents3139" ["related_di_name"]=> string(13) "Documents3148" ["title"]=> string(136) "HCJFH 2624/16 - Masudi et al. v. Commander of IDF Forces in the West Bank Request for Further Hearing and Request for an Interim Order " ["documentDate"]=> string(19) "2016-03-30 00:00:00" ["type_di_name"]=> string(5) "03_22" } [3]=> array(5) { ["di_name"]=> string(13) "Documents3139" ["related_di_name"]=> string(11) "Updates1696" ["title"]=> string(198) "HaMoked to HCJ in motion for further hearing on punitive house demolitions: “Six justices of the Honorable Court believe themselves bound by case law… and are uncomfortable with this position”" ["documentDate"]=> string(19) "2016-03-30 00:00:00" ["type_di_name"]=> string(7) "updates" } [4]=> array(5) { ["di_name"]=> string(13) "Documents3139" ["related_di_name"]=> string(11) "Updates1688" ["title"]=> string(248) "HaMoked to the HCJ on the issue of legality of punitive demolition: the time is ripe for a discussion of the principle issues before an expanded panel, in view of the fact that six of the justices are in favour of revisiting the prevailing case law" ["documentDate"]=> string(19) "2016-03-27 00:00:00" ["type_di_name"]=> string(7) "updates" } [5]=> array(5) { ["di_name"]=> string(13) "Documents3139" ["related_di_name"]=> string(11) "Updates1690" ["title"]=> string(147) "HCJ majority approved another punitive demolition in Hebron: but two of the justices were in favor of revising the core issues in an expanded panel" ["documentDate"]=> string(19) "2016-03-23 00:00:00" ["type_di_name"]=> string(7) "updates" } [6]=> array(5) { ["di_name"]=> string(13) "Documents3139" ["related_di_name"]=> string(13) "Documents3087" ["title"]=> string(114) "HCJ 1630/16 - Masudi et al. v. Commander of IDF Forces in the West Bank Petition for Order Nisi and Interim Order " ["documentDate"]=> string(19) "2016-02-28 00:00:00" ["type_di_name"]=> string(5) "03_22" } } array(7) { [0]=> array(5) { ["di_name"]=> string(13) "Documents3139" ["related_di_name"]=> string(13) "Documents3149" ["title"]=> string(83) "HCJFH 2624/16 - Masudi et al. v. Commander of IDF Forces in the West Bank Decision" ["documentDate"]=> string(19) "2016-03-31 00:00:00" ["type_di_name"]=> string(18) "Document Types1000" } [1]=> array(5) { ["di_name"]=> string(13) "Documents3139" ["related_di_name"]=> string(11) "Updates1697" ["title"]=> string(266) "HCJ rejects motion for further hearing on punitive house demolitions: “This is not the appropriate case for considering further review of the issues of principle relating to the use of Regulation 119 before an expanded panel of this Court”, ruled President Naor " ["documentDate"]=> string(19) "2016-03-31 00:00:00" ["type_di_name"]=> string(7) "updates" } [2]=> array(5) { ["di_name"]=> string(13) "Documents3139" ["related_di_name"]=> string(13) "Documents3148" ["title"]=> string(136) "HCJFH 2624/16 - Masudi et al. v. Commander of IDF Forces in the West Bank Request for Further Hearing and Request for an Interim Order " ["documentDate"]=> string(19) "2016-03-30 00:00:00" ["type_di_name"]=> string(5) "03_22" } [3]=> array(5) { ["di_name"]=> string(13) "Documents3139" ["related_di_name"]=> string(11) "Updates1696" ["title"]=> string(198) "HaMoked to HCJ in motion for further hearing on punitive house demolitions: “Six justices of the Honorable Court believe themselves bound by case law… and are uncomfortable with this position”" ["documentDate"]=> string(19) "2016-03-30 00:00:00" ["type_di_name"]=> string(7) "updates" } [4]=> array(5) { ["di_name"]=> string(13) "Documents3139" ["related_di_name"]=> string(11) "Updates1688" ["title"]=> string(248) "HaMoked to the HCJ on the issue of legality of punitive demolition: the time is ripe for a discussion of the principle issues before an expanded panel, in view of the fact that six of the justices are in favour of revisiting the prevailing case law" ["documentDate"]=> string(19) "2016-03-27 00:00:00" ["type_di_name"]=> string(7) "updates" } [5]=> array(5) { ["di_name"]=> string(13) "Documents3139" ["related_di_name"]=> string(11) "Updates1690" ["title"]=> string(147) "HCJ majority approved another punitive demolition in Hebron: but two of the justices were in favor of revising the core issues in an expanded panel" ["documentDate"]=> string(19) "2016-03-23 00:00:00" ["type_di_name"]=> string(7) "updates" } [6]=> array(5) { ["di_name"]=> string(13) "Documents3139" ["related_di_name"]=> string(13) "Documents3087" ["title"]=> string(114) "HCJ 1630/16 - Masudi et al. v. Commander of IDF Forces in the West Bank Petition for Order Nisi and Interim Order " ["documentDate"]=> string(19) "2016-02-28 00:00:00" ["type_di_name"]=> string(5) "03_22" } } array(7) { [0]=> array(5) { ["di_name"]=> string(13) "Documents3139" ["related_di_name"]=> string(13) "Documents3149" ["title"]=> string(83) "HCJFH 2624/16 - Masudi et al. v. Commander of IDF Forces in the West Bank Decision" ["documentDate"]=> string(19) "2016-03-31 00:00:00" ["type_di_name"]=> string(18) "Document Types1000" } [1]=> array(5) { ["di_name"]=> string(13) "Documents3139" ["related_di_name"]=> string(11) "Updates1697" ["title"]=> string(266) "HCJ rejects motion for further hearing on punitive house demolitions: “This is not the appropriate case for considering further review of the issues of principle relating to the use of Regulation 119 before an expanded panel of this Court”, ruled President Naor " ["documentDate"]=> string(19) "2016-03-31 00:00:00" ["type_di_name"]=> string(7) "updates" } [2]=> array(5) { ["di_name"]=> string(13) "Documents3139" ["related_di_name"]=> string(13) "Documents3148" ["title"]=> string(136) "HCJFH 2624/16 - Masudi et al. v. Commander of IDF Forces in the West Bank Request for Further Hearing and Request for an Interim Order " ["documentDate"]=> string(19) "2016-03-30 00:00:00" ["type_di_name"]=> string(5) "03_22" } [3]=> array(5) { ["di_name"]=> string(13) "Documents3139" ["related_di_name"]=> string(11) "Updates1696" ["title"]=> string(198) "HaMoked to HCJ in motion for further hearing on punitive house demolitions: “Six justices of the Honorable Court believe themselves bound by case law… and are uncomfortable with this position”" ["documentDate"]=> string(19) "2016-03-30 00:00:00" ["type_di_name"]=> string(7) "updates" } [4]=> array(5) { ["di_name"]=> string(13) "Documents3139" ["related_di_name"]=> string(11) "Updates1688" ["title"]=> string(248) "HaMoked to the HCJ on the issue of legality of punitive demolition: the time is ripe for a discussion of the principle issues before an expanded panel, in view of the fact that six of the justices are in favour of revisiting the prevailing case law" ["documentDate"]=> string(19) "2016-03-27 00:00:00" ["type_di_name"]=> string(7) "updates" } [5]=> array(5) { ["di_name"]=> string(13) "Documents3139" ["related_di_name"]=> string(11) "Updates1690" ["title"]=> string(147) "HCJ majority approved another punitive demolition in Hebron: but two of the justices were in favor of revising the core issues in an expanded panel" ["documentDate"]=> string(19) "2016-03-23 00:00:00" ["type_di_name"]=> string(7) "updates" } [6]=> array(5) { ["di_name"]=> string(13) "Documents3139" ["related_di_name"]=> string(13) "Documents3087" ["title"]=> string(114) "HCJ 1630/16 - Masudi et al. v. Commander of IDF Forces in the West Bank Petition for Order Nisi and Interim Order " ["documentDate"]=> string(19) "2016-02-28 00:00:00" ["type_di_name"]=> string(5) "03_22" } } array(7) { [0]=> array(5) { ["di_name"]=> string(13) "Documents3139" ["related_di_name"]=> string(13) "Documents3149" ["title"]=> string(83) "HCJFH 2624/16 - Masudi et al. v. Commander of IDF Forces in the West Bank Decision" ["documentDate"]=> string(19) "2016-03-31 00:00:00" ["type_di_name"]=> string(18) "Document Types1000" } [1]=> array(5) { ["di_name"]=> string(13) "Documents3139" ["related_di_name"]=> string(11) "Updates1697" ["title"]=> string(266) "HCJ rejects motion for further hearing on punitive house demolitions: “This is not the appropriate case for considering further review of the issues of principle relating to the use of Regulation 119 before an expanded panel of this Court”, ruled President Naor " ["documentDate"]=> string(19) "2016-03-31 00:00:00" ["type_di_name"]=> string(7) "updates" } [2]=> array(5) { ["di_name"]=> string(13) "Documents3139" ["related_di_name"]=> string(13) "Documents3148" ["title"]=> string(136) "HCJFH 2624/16 - Masudi et al. v. Commander of IDF Forces in the West Bank Request for Further Hearing and Request for an Interim Order " ["documentDate"]=> string(19) "2016-03-30 00:00:00" ["type_di_name"]=> string(5) "03_22" } [3]=> array(5) { ["di_name"]=> string(13) "Documents3139" ["related_di_name"]=> string(11) "Updates1696" ["title"]=> string(198) "HaMoked to HCJ in motion for further hearing on punitive house demolitions: “Six justices of the Honorable Court believe themselves bound by case law… and are uncomfortable with this position”" ["documentDate"]=> string(19) "2016-03-30 00:00:00" ["type_di_name"]=> string(7) "updates" } [4]=> array(5) { ["di_name"]=> string(13) "Documents3139" ["related_di_name"]=> string(11) "Updates1688" ["title"]=> string(248) "HaMoked to the HCJ on the issue of legality of punitive demolition: the time is ripe for a discussion of the principle issues before an expanded panel, in view of the fact that six of the justices are in favour of revisiting the prevailing case law" ["documentDate"]=> string(19) "2016-03-27 00:00:00" ["type_di_name"]=> string(7) "updates" } [5]=> array(5) { ["di_name"]=> string(13) "Documents3139" ["related_di_name"]=> string(11) "Updates1690" ["title"]=> string(147) "HCJ majority approved another punitive demolition in Hebron: but two of the justices were in favor of revising the core issues in an expanded panel" ["documentDate"]=> string(19) "2016-03-23 00:00:00" ["type_di_name"]=> string(7) "updates" } [6]=> array(5) { ["di_name"]=> string(13) "Documents3139" ["related_di_name"]=> string(13) "Documents3087" ["title"]=> string(114) "HCJ 1630/16 - Masudi et al. v. Commander of IDF Forces in the West Bank Petition for Order Nisi and Interim Order " ["documentDate"]=> string(19) "2016-02-28 00:00:00" ["type_di_name"]=> string(5) "03_22" } }
HCJ 1630/16 - Masudi et al. v. Commander of IDF Forces in the West Bank Petition for Order Nisi and Interim Order
28.02.2016 | עתירה לבג"ץ
Read more

Related topics

House Demolitions House Demolitions