Center for the Defence of the Individual - HCJ 6745/15 - Abu Hashiyeh et al. v. Military Commander of the West Bank Judgement
التحديثات HE wheel chair icon
Display File
Judgment | Judgment / Supreme Court | 01.12.2015
HCJ 6745/15 - Abu Hashiyeh et al. v. Military Commander of the West Bank Judgement

Judgment on HaMoked's petition against the State's intention to demolish the home of a suspect in a stabbing in Tel Aviv in November 2014. The Court accepts the petition, in a majority of two to one, and instructs the cancellation of the demolition order due to the substantial delay in issuing it. In the Judgment, the majority judges rule that "application of the authority must be related to the legal justification for its use, that is, the order must be issued because of the attack committed by the relative who lived in the house to which the order applies, and not due to later, unrelated events".


Updates

The HCJ rejects a petition to demolish the family homes of Israeli Jewish assailants: “Given the difficulties arising from exercising the authority under Regulation 119… it seems it would be wrong to extend it to other attribution groups regarding whom even the state considers it unnecessary at this stage”
05.07.2017
Read more
The HCJ in a rare decision in HaMoked’s petition against a punitive demolition order: the family home in the Askar Refugee Camp will not be demolished; “the Respondent’s exercise of the authority about a year after the [suspect]’s murderous deeds cannot anyhow lead to the desired and legitimate deterrence outcome”
01.12.2015
Read more

Related documents

array(6) { [0]=> array(5) { ["di_name"]=> string(13) "Documents2951" ["related_di_name"]=> string(11) "Updates1904" ["title"]=> string(313) "The HCJ rejects a petition to demolish the family homes of Israeli Jewish assailants: “Given the difficulties arising from exercising the authority under Regulation 119… it seems it would be wrong to extend it to other attribution groups regarding whom even the state considers it unnecessary at this stage”" ["documentDate"]=> string(19) "2017-07-05 00:00:00" ["type_di_name"]=> string(7) "updates" } [1]=> array(5) { ["di_name"]=> string(13) "Documents2951" ["related_di_name"]=> string(11) "Updates1625" ["title"]=> string(325) "The HCJ in a rare decision in HaMoked’s petition against a punitive demolition order: the family home in the Askar Refugee Camp will not be demolished; “the Respondent’s exercise of the authority about a year after the [suspect]’s murderous deeds cannot anyhow lead to the desired and legitimate deterrence outcome”" ["documentDate"]=> string(19) "2015-12-01 00:00:00" ["type_di_name"]=> string(7) "updates" } [2]=> array(5) { ["di_name"]=> string(13) "Documents2951" ["related_di_name"]=> string(13) "Documents2920" ["title"]=> string(95) "HCJ 6745/15 - Abu Hashiyeh et al. v. Military Commander of the West Bank Area et al. Transcript" ["documentDate"]=> string(19) "2015-11-11 00:00:00" ["type_di_name"]=> string(5) "03_57" } [3]=> array(5) { ["di_name"]=> string(13) "Documents2951" ["related_di_name"]=> string(13) "Documents2890" ["title"]=> string(114) "HCJ 6745/15 - Abu Hashiyeh et al. v. Military Commander of the West Bank Area et al. Notice on behalf of the State" ["documentDate"]=> string(19) "2015-10-28 00:00:00" ["type_di_name"]=> string(5) "03_26" } [4]=> array(5) { ["di_name"]=> string(13) "Documents2951" ["related_di_name"]=> string(13) "Documents2859" ["title"]=> string(116) "HCJ 6745/15 - Abu Hashiyeh et al. v. Military Commander of the West Bank Area et al. Response on behalf of the State" ["documentDate"]=> string(19) "2015-10-19 00:00:00" ["type_di_name"]=> string(5) "03_23" } [5]=> array(5) { ["di_name"]=> string(13) "Documents2951" ["related_di_name"]=> string(13) "Documents2827" ["title"]=> string(93) "HCJ 6745/15 - Abu Hashiyeh et al. v. Military Commander of the West Bank Area et al. Petition" ["documentDate"]=> string(19) "2015-10-12 00:00:00" ["type_di_name"]=> string(5) "03_22" } } array(6) { [0]=> array(5) { ["di_name"]=> string(13) "Documents2951" ["related_di_name"]=> string(11) "Updates1904" ["title"]=> string(313) "The HCJ rejects a petition to demolish the family homes of Israeli Jewish assailants: “Given the difficulties arising from exercising the authority under Regulation 119… it seems it would be wrong to extend it to other attribution groups regarding whom even the state considers it unnecessary at this stage”" ["documentDate"]=> string(19) "2017-07-05 00:00:00" ["type_di_name"]=> string(7) "updates" } [1]=> array(5) { ["di_name"]=> string(13) "Documents2951" ["related_di_name"]=> string(11) "Updates1625" ["title"]=> string(325) "The HCJ in a rare decision in HaMoked’s petition against a punitive demolition order: the family home in the Askar Refugee Camp will not be demolished; “the Respondent’s exercise of the authority about a year after the [suspect]’s murderous deeds cannot anyhow lead to the desired and legitimate deterrence outcome”" ["documentDate"]=> string(19) "2015-12-01 00:00:00" ["type_di_name"]=> string(7) "updates" } [2]=> array(5) { ["di_name"]=> string(13) "Documents2951" ["related_di_name"]=> string(13) "Documents2920" ["title"]=> string(95) "HCJ 6745/15 - Abu Hashiyeh et al. v. Military Commander of the West Bank Area et al. Transcript" ["documentDate"]=> string(19) "2015-11-11 00:00:00" ["type_di_name"]=> string(5) "03_57" } [3]=> array(5) { ["di_name"]=> string(13) "Documents2951" ["related_di_name"]=> string(13) "Documents2890" ["title"]=> string(114) "HCJ 6745/15 - Abu Hashiyeh et al. v. Military Commander of the West Bank Area et al. Notice on behalf of the State" ["documentDate"]=> string(19) "2015-10-28 00:00:00" ["type_di_name"]=> string(5) "03_26" } [4]=> array(5) { ["di_name"]=> string(13) "Documents2951" ["related_di_name"]=> string(13) "Documents2859" ["title"]=> string(116) "HCJ 6745/15 - Abu Hashiyeh et al. v. Military Commander of the West Bank Area et al. Response on behalf of the State" ["documentDate"]=> string(19) "2015-10-19 00:00:00" ["type_di_name"]=> string(5) "03_23" } [5]=> array(5) { ["di_name"]=> string(13) "Documents2951" ["related_di_name"]=> string(13) "Documents2827" ["title"]=> string(93) "HCJ 6745/15 - Abu Hashiyeh et al. v. Military Commander of the West Bank Area et al. Petition" ["documentDate"]=> string(19) "2015-10-12 00:00:00" ["type_di_name"]=> string(5) "03_22" } } array(6) { [0]=> array(5) { ["di_name"]=> string(13) "Documents2951" ["related_di_name"]=> string(11) "Updates1904" ["title"]=> string(313) "The HCJ rejects a petition to demolish the family homes of Israeli Jewish assailants: “Given the difficulties arising from exercising the authority under Regulation 119… it seems it would be wrong to extend it to other attribution groups regarding whom even the state considers it unnecessary at this stage”" ["documentDate"]=> string(19) "2017-07-05 00:00:00" ["type_di_name"]=> string(7) "updates" } [1]=> array(5) { ["di_name"]=> string(13) "Documents2951" ["related_di_name"]=> string(11) "Updates1625" ["title"]=> string(325) "The HCJ in a rare decision in HaMoked’s petition against a punitive demolition order: the family home in the Askar Refugee Camp will not be demolished; “the Respondent’s exercise of the authority about a year after the [suspect]’s murderous deeds cannot anyhow lead to the desired and legitimate deterrence outcome”" ["documentDate"]=> string(19) "2015-12-01 00:00:00" ["type_di_name"]=> string(7) "updates" } [2]=> array(5) { ["di_name"]=> string(13) "Documents2951" ["related_di_name"]=> string(13) "Documents2920" ["title"]=> string(95) "HCJ 6745/15 - Abu Hashiyeh et al. v. Military Commander of the West Bank Area et al. Transcript" ["documentDate"]=> string(19) "2015-11-11 00:00:00" ["type_di_name"]=> string(5) "03_57" } [3]=> array(5) { ["di_name"]=> string(13) "Documents2951" ["related_di_name"]=> string(13) "Documents2890" ["title"]=> string(114) "HCJ 6745/15 - Abu Hashiyeh et al. v. Military Commander of the West Bank Area et al. Notice on behalf of the State" ["documentDate"]=> string(19) "2015-10-28 00:00:00" ["type_di_name"]=> string(5) "03_26" } [4]=> array(5) { ["di_name"]=> string(13) "Documents2951" ["related_di_name"]=> string(13) "Documents2859" ["title"]=> string(116) "HCJ 6745/15 - Abu Hashiyeh et al. v. Military Commander of the West Bank Area et al. Response on behalf of the State" ["documentDate"]=> string(19) "2015-10-19 00:00:00" ["type_di_name"]=> string(5) "03_23" } [5]=> array(5) { ["di_name"]=> string(13) "Documents2951" ["related_di_name"]=> string(13) "Documents2827" ["title"]=> string(93) "HCJ 6745/15 - Abu Hashiyeh et al. v. Military Commander of the West Bank Area et al. Petition" ["documentDate"]=> string(19) "2015-10-12 00:00:00" ["type_di_name"]=> string(5) "03_22" } }
HCJ 6745/15 - Abu Hashiyeh et al. v. Military Commander of the West Bank Area et al. Transcript
11.11.2015 | פרוטוקול
Read more
array(6) { [0]=> array(5) { ["di_name"]=> string(13) "Documents2951" ["related_di_name"]=> string(11) "Updates1904" ["title"]=> string(313) "The HCJ rejects a petition to demolish the family homes of Israeli Jewish assailants: “Given the difficulties arising from exercising the authority under Regulation 119… it seems it would be wrong to extend it to other attribution groups regarding whom even the state considers it unnecessary at this stage”" ["documentDate"]=> string(19) "2017-07-05 00:00:00" ["type_di_name"]=> string(7) "updates" } [1]=> array(5) { ["di_name"]=> string(13) "Documents2951" ["related_di_name"]=> string(11) "Updates1625" ["title"]=> string(325) "The HCJ in a rare decision in HaMoked’s petition against a punitive demolition order: the family home in the Askar Refugee Camp will not be demolished; “the Respondent’s exercise of the authority about a year after the [suspect]’s murderous deeds cannot anyhow lead to the desired and legitimate deterrence outcome”" ["documentDate"]=> string(19) "2015-12-01 00:00:00" ["type_di_name"]=> string(7) "updates" } [2]=> array(5) { ["di_name"]=> string(13) "Documents2951" ["related_di_name"]=> string(13) "Documents2920" ["title"]=> string(95) "HCJ 6745/15 - Abu Hashiyeh et al. v. Military Commander of the West Bank Area et al. Transcript" ["documentDate"]=> string(19) "2015-11-11 00:00:00" ["type_di_name"]=> string(5) "03_57" } [3]=> array(5) { ["di_name"]=> string(13) "Documents2951" ["related_di_name"]=> string(13) "Documents2890" ["title"]=> string(114) "HCJ 6745/15 - Abu Hashiyeh et al. v. Military Commander of the West Bank Area et al. Notice on behalf of the State" ["documentDate"]=> string(19) "2015-10-28 00:00:00" ["type_di_name"]=> string(5) "03_26" } [4]=> array(5) { ["di_name"]=> string(13) "Documents2951" ["related_di_name"]=> string(13) "Documents2859" ["title"]=> string(116) "HCJ 6745/15 - Abu Hashiyeh et al. v. Military Commander of the West Bank Area et al. Response on behalf of the State" ["documentDate"]=> string(19) "2015-10-19 00:00:00" ["type_di_name"]=> string(5) "03_23" } [5]=> array(5) { ["di_name"]=> string(13) "Documents2951" ["related_di_name"]=> string(13) "Documents2827" ["title"]=> string(93) "HCJ 6745/15 - Abu Hashiyeh et al. v. Military Commander of the West Bank Area et al. Petition" ["documentDate"]=> string(19) "2015-10-12 00:00:00" ["type_di_name"]=> string(5) "03_22" } }
HCJ 6745/15 - Abu Hashiyeh et al. v. Military Commander of the West Bank Area et al. Notice on behalf of the State
28.10.2015 | הודעה
Read more
array(6) { [0]=> array(5) { ["di_name"]=> string(13) "Documents2951" ["related_di_name"]=> string(11) "Updates1904" ["title"]=> string(313) "The HCJ rejects a petition to demolish the family homes of Israeli Jewish assailants: “Given the difficulties arising from exercising the authority under Regulation 119… it seems it would be wrong to extend it to other attribution groups regarding whom even the state considers it unnecessary at this stage”" ["documentDate"]=> string(19) "2017-07-05 00:00:00" ["type_di_name"]=> string(7) "updates" } [1]=> array(5) { ["di_name"]=> string(13) "Documents2951" ["related_di_name"]=> string(11) "Updates1625" ["title"]=> string(325) "The HCJ in a rare decision in HaMoked’s petition against a punitive demolition order: the family home in the Askar Refugee Camp will not be demolished; “the Respondent’s exercise of the authority about a year after the [suspect]’s murderous deeds cannot anyhow lead to the desired and legitimate deterrence outcome”" ["documentDate"]=> string(19) "2015-12-01 00:00:00" ["type_di_name"]=> string(7) "updates" } [2]=> array(5) { ["di_name"]=> string(13) "Documents2951" ["related_di_name"]=> string(13) "Documents2920" ["title"]=> string(95) "HCJ 6745/15 - Abu Hashiyeh et al. v. Military Commander of the West Bank Area et al. Transcript" ["documentDate"]=> string(19) "2015-11-11 00:00:00" ["type_di_name"]=> string(5) "03_57" } [3]=> array(5) { ["di_name"]=> string(13) "Documents2951" ["related_di_name"]=> string(13) "Documents2890" ["title"]=> string(114) "HCJ 6745/15 - Abu Hashiyeh et al. v. Military Commander of the West Bank Area et al. Notice on behalf of the State" ["documentDate"]=> string(19) "2015-10-28 00:00:00" ["type_di_name"]=> string(5) "03_26" } [4]=> array(5) { ["di_name"]=> string(13) "Documents2951" ["related_di_name"]=> string(13) "Documents2859" ["title"]=> string(116) "HCJ 6745/15 - Abu Hashiyeh et al. v. Military Commander of the West Bank Area et al. Response on behalf of the State" ["documentDate"]=> string(19) "2015-10-19 00:00:00" ["type_di_name"]=> string(5) "03_23" } [5]=> array(5) { ["di_name"]=> string(13) "Documents2951" ["related_di_name"]=> string(13) "Documents2827" ["title"]=> string(93) "HCJ 6745/15 - Abu Hashiyeh et al. v. Military Commander of the West Bank Area et al. Petition" ["documentDate"]=> string(19) "2015-10-12 00:00:00" ["type_di_name"]=> string(5) "03_22" } }
HCJ 6745/15 - Abu Hashiyeh et al. v. Military Commander of the West Bank Area et al. Response on behalf of the State
19.10.2015 | תגובה
Read more
array(6) { [0]=> array(5) { ["di_name"]=> string(13) "Documents2951" ["related_di_name"]=> string(11) "Updates1904" ["title"]=> string(313) "The HCJ rejects a petition to demolish the family homes of Israeli Jewish assailants: “Given the difficulties arising from exercising the authority under Regulation 119… it seems it would be wrong to extend it to other attribution groups regarding whom even the state considers it unnecessary at this stage”" ["documentDate"]=> string(19) "2017-07-05 00:00:00" ["type_di_name"]=> string(7) "updates" } [1]=> array(5) { ["di_name"]=> string(13) "Documents2951" ["related_di_name"]=> string(11) "Updates1625" ["title"]=> string(325) "The HCJ in a rare decision in HaMoked’s petition against a punitive demolition order: the family home in the Askar Refugee Camp will not be demolished; “the Respondent’s exercise of the authority about a year after the [suspect]’s murderous deeds cannot anyhow lead to the desired and legitimate deterrence outcome”" ["documentDate"]=> string(19) "2015-12-01 00:00:00" ["type_di_name"]=> string(7) "updates" } [2]=> array(5) { ["di_name"]=> string(13) "Documents2951" ["related_di_name"]=> string(13) "Documents2920" ["title"]=> string(95) "HCJ 6745/15 - Abu Hashiyeh et al. v. Military Commander of the West Bank Area et al. Transcript" ["documentDate"]=> string(19) "2015-11-11 00:00:00" ["type_di_name"]=> string(5) "03_57" } [3]=> array(5) { ["di_name"]=> string(13) "Documents2951" ["related_di_name"]=> string(13) "Documents2890" ["title"]=> string(114) "HCJ 6745/15 - Abu Hashiyeh et al. v. Military Commander of the West Bank Area et al. Notice on behalf of the State" ["documentDate"]=> string(19) "2015-10-28 00:00:00" ["type_di_name"]=> string(5) "03_26" } [4]=> array(5) { ["di_name"]=> string(13) "Documents2951" ["related_di_name"]=> string(13) "Documents2859" ["title"]=> string(116) "HCJ 6745/15 - Abu Hashiyeh et al. v. Military Commander of the West Bank Area et al. Response on behalf of the State" ["documentDate"]=> string(19) "2015-10-19 00:00:00" ["type_di_name"]=> string(5) "03_23" } [5]=> array(5) { ["di_name"]=> string(13) "Documents2951" ["related_di_name"]=> string(13) "Documents2827" ["title"]=> string(93) "HCJ 6745/15 - Abu Hashiyeh et al. v. Military Commander of the West Bank Area et al. Petition" ["documentDate"]=> string(19) "2015-10-12 00:00:00" ["type_di_name"]=> string(5) "03_22" } }
HCJ 6745/15 - Abu Hashiyeh et al. v. Military Commander of the West Bank Area et al. Petition
12.10.2015 | עתירה לבג"ץ
Read more

Related topics

House Demolitions House Demolitions