Center for the Defence of the Individual - HCJFH 360/15 - HaMoked et al. v. Minister of Defense et al. Judgement
Judgment | Judgment / Supreme Court | 12.11.2015
HCJFH 360/15 - HaMoked et al. v. Minister of Defense et al. Judgement

The Court rejects a request for a new hearing on the principled petition against the punitive home demolition policy, submitted by HaMoked and seven other human rights organizations. The Court rules that there is no place for renewed discussion of the organizations' claims, stating that "this proceeding was intended for clear and detailed rulings by the Court, and not for questions that the Court does not discuss". In conclusion, the Court repeats its statements from the principled petition, that "there is no doubt that the issue of punitive home demolitions raises 'difficult questions' and sometimes even 'a moral dilemma'" and that "the State has a duty to continue to examine the efficacy of the described policy".


Related documents

array(7) { [0]=> array(5) { ["di_name"]=> string(13) "Documents2921" ["related_di_name"]=> string(11) "Updates1639" ["title"]=> string(247) "The HCJ approves the punitive demolition of two homes in Jabal al Mukabber: in the dissenting opinion, Justice Mazuz held that “a sanction which directs itself at harming the innocent cannot, in my opinion, be justified under any circumstance”" ["documentDate"]=> string(19) "2015-12-23 00:00:00" ["type_di_name"]=> string(7) "updates" } [1]=> array(5) { ["di_name"]=> string(13) "Documents2921" ["related_di_name"]=> string(11) "Updates1608" ["title"]=> string(273) "The HCJ dismissed the motion for further hearing before an expanded panel in the public petition against punitive home demolitions: Court President Naor ruled that “this petition, at the time it was filed, was not the optimal vehicle for the applicants’ arguments…”" ["documentDate"]=> string(19) "2015-11-15 00:00:00" ["type_di_name"]=> string(7) "updates" } [2]=> array(5) { ["di_name"]=> string(13) "Documents2921" ["related_di_name"]=> string(13) "Documents2687" ["title"]=> string(143) "HCJFH 063/15 - HaMoked Center for the Defence of the Individual et al. v. Minister of Defense et al. Applicants' Request to Submit an Authority" ["documentDate"]=> string(19) "2015-05-11 00:00:00" ["type_di_name"]=> string(5) "03_17" } [3]=> array(5) { ["di_name"]=> string(13) "Documents2921" ["related_di_name"]=> string(13) "Documents2686" ["title"]=> string(75) "Re: HCJFH 360/15 – Petitioners’ Motion for Leave to Submit an Authority" ["documentDate"]=> string(19) "2015-05-10 00:00:00" ["type_di_name"]=> string(5) "03_23" } [4]=> array(5) { ["di_name"]=> string(13) "Documents2921" ["related_di_name"]=> string(13) "Documents2625" ["title"]=> string(116) "HCJFH 360/15 - HaMoked - Center for the Defence of the Individual et al.v. Minister of Defense Respondents' Response" ["documentDate"]=> string(19) "2015-02-12 00:00:00" ["type_di_name"]=> string(5) "03_23" } [5]=> array(5) { ["di_name"]=> string(13) "Documents2921" ["related_di_name"]=> string(13) "Documents2595" ["title"]=> string(121) "HCJFH 360/15 HaMoked - Center for the Defence of the Individual et al.v. Minister of Defense Request for Further Hearing " ["documentDate"]=> string(19) "2015-01-15 00:00:00" ["type_di_name"]=> string(5) "03_17" } [6]=> array(5) { ["di_name"]=> string(13) "Documents2921" ["related_di_name"]=> string(11) "Updates1429" ["title"]=> string(248) "The court denied the general petition filed by HaMoked and other human rights organizations against the punitive house demolition policy: the court ruled that the state had the authority to demolish houses, but it should exercise it proportionately" ["documentDate"]=> string(19) "2015-01-01 00:00:00" ["type_di_name"]=> string(7) "updates" } } array(7) { [0]=> array(5) { ["di_name"]=> string(13) "Documents2921" ["related_di_name"]=> string(11) "Updates1639" ["title"]=> string(247) "The HCJ approves the punitive demolition of two homes in Jabal al Mukabber: in the dissenting opinion, Justice Mazuz held that “a sanction which directs itself at harming the innocent cannot, in my opinion, be justified under any circumstance”" ["documentDate"]=> string(19) "2015-12-23 00:00:00" ["type_di_name"]=> string(7) "updates" } [1]=> array(5) { ["di_name"]=> string(13) "Documents2921" ["related_di_name"]=> string(11) "Updates1608" ["title"]=> string(273) "The HCJ dismissed the motion for further hearing before an expanded panel in the public petition against punitive home demolitions: Court President Naor ruled that “this petition, at the time it was filed, was not the optimal vehicle for the applicants’ arguments…”" ["documentDate"]=> string(19) "2015-11-15 00:00:00" ["type_di_name"]=> string(7) "updates" } [2]=> array(5) { ["di_name"]=> string(13) "Documents2921" ["related_di_name"]=> string(13) "Documents2687" ["title"]=> string(143) "HCJFH 063/15 - HaMoked Center for the Defence of the Individual et al. v. Minister of Defense et al. Applicants' Request to Submit an Authority" ["documentDate"]=> string(19) "2015-05-11 00:00:00" ["type_di_name"]=> string(5) "03_17" } [3]=> array(5) { ["di_name"]=> string(13) "Documents2921" ["related_di_name"]=> string(13) "Documents2686" ["title"]=> string(75) "Re: HCJFH 360/15 – Petitioners’ Motion for Leave to Submit an Authority" ["documentDate"]=> string(19) "2015-05-10 00:00:00" ["type_di_name"]=> string(5) "03_23" } [4]=> array(5) { ["di_name"]=> string(13) "Documents2921" ["related_di_name"]=> string(13) "Documents2625" ["title"]=> string(116) "HCJFH 360/15 - HaMoked - Center for the Defence of the Individual et al.v. Minister of Defense Respondents' Response" ["documentDate"]=> string(19) "2015-02-12 00:00:00" ["type_di_name"]=> string(5) "03_23" } [5]=> array(5) { ["di_name"]=> string(13) "Documents2921" ["related_di_name"]=> string(13) "Documents2595" ["title"]=> string(121) "HCJFH 360/15 HaMoked - Center for the Defence of the Individual et al.v. Minister of Defense Request for Further Hearing " ["documentDate"]=> string(19) "2015-01-15 00:00:00" ["type_di_name"]=> string(5) "03_17" } [6]=> array(5) { ["di_name"]=> string(13) "Documents2921" ["related_di_name"]=> string(11) "Updates1429" ["title"]=> string(248) "The court denied the general petition filed by HaMoked and other human rights organizations against the punitive house demolition policy: the court ruled that the state had the authority to demolish houses, but it should exercise it proportionately" ["documentDate"]=> string(19) "2015-01-01 00:00:00" ["type_di_name"]=> string(7) "updates" } } array(7) { [0]=> array(5) { ["di_name"]=> string(13) "Documents2921" ["related_di_name"]=> string(11) "Updates1639" ["title"]=> string(247) "The HCJ approves the punitive demolition of two homes in Jabal al Mukabber: in the dissenting opinion, Justice Mazuz held that “a sanction which directs itself at harming the innocent cannot, in my opinion, be justified under any circumstance”" ["documentDate"]=> string(19) "2015-12-23 00:00:00" ["type_di_name"]=> string(7) "updates" } [1]=> array(5) { ["di_name"]=> string(13) "Documents2921" ["related_di_name"]=> string(11) "Updates1608" ["title"]=> string(273) "The HCJ dismissed the motion for further hearing before an expanded panel in the public petition against punitive home demolitions: Court President Naor ruled that “this petition, at the time it was filed, was not the optimal vehicle for the applicants’ arguments…”" ["documentDate"]=> string(19) "2015-11-15 00:00:00" ["type_di_name"]=> string(7) "updates" } [2]=> array(5) { ["di_name"]=> string(13) "Documents2921" ["related_di_name"]=> string(13) "Documents2687" ["title"]=> string(143) "HCJFH 063/15 - HaMoked Center for the Defence of the Individual et al. v. Minister of Defense et al. Applicants' Request to Submit an Authority" ["documentDate"]=> string(19) "2015-05-11 00:00:00" ["type_di_name"]=> string(5) "03_17" } [3]=> array(5) { ["di_name"]=> string(13) "Documents2921" ["related_di_name"]=> string(13) "Documents2686" ["title"]=> string(75) "Re: HCJFH 360/15 – Petitioners’ Motion for Leave to Submit an Authority" ["documentDate"]=> string(19) "2015-05-10 00:00:00" ["type_di_name"]=> string(5) "03_23" } [4]=> array(5) { ["di_name"]=> string(13) "Documents2921" ["related_di_name"]=> string(13) "Documents2625" ["title"]=> string(116) "HCJFH 360/15 - HaMoked - Center for the Defence of the Individual et al.v. Minister of Defense Respondents' Response" ["documentDate"]=> string(19) "2015-02-12 00:00:00" ["type_di_name"]=> string(5) "03_23" } [5]=> array(5) { ["di_name"]=> string(13) "Documents2921" ["related_di_name"]=> string(13) "Documents2595" ["title"]=> string(121) "HCJFH 360/15 HaMoked - Center for the Defence of the Individual et al.v. Minister of Defense Request for Further Hearing " ["documentDate"]=> string(19) "2015-01-15 00:00:00" ["type_di_name"]=> string(5) "03_17" } [6]=> array(5) { ["di_name"]=> string(13) "Documents2921" ["related_di_name"]=> string(11) "Updates1429" ["title"]=> string(248) "The court denied the general petition filed by HaMoked and other human rights organizations against the punitive house demolition policy: the court ruled that the state had the authority to demolish houses, but it should exercise it proportionately" ["documentDate"]=> string(19) "2015-01-01 00:00:00" ["type_di_name"]=> string(7) "updates" } }
HCJFH 063/15 - HaMoked Center for the Defence of the Individual et al. v. Minister of Defense et al. Applicants' Request to Submit an Authority
11.05.2015 | בקשה
Read more
array(7) { [0]=> array(5) { ["di_name"]=> string(13) "Documents2921" ["related_di_name"]=> string(11) "Updates1639" ["title"]=> string(247) "The HCJ approves the punitive demolition of two homes in Jabal al Mukabber: in the dissenting opinion, Justice Mazuz held that “a sanction which directs itself at harming the innocent cannot, in my opinion, be justified under any circumstance”" ["documentDate"]=> string(19) "2015-12-23 00:00:00" ["type_di_name"]=> string(7) "updates" } [1]=> array(5) { ["di_name"]=> string(13) "Documents2921" ["related_di_name"]=> string(11) "Updates1608" ["title"]=> string(273) "The HCJ dismissed the motion for further hearing before an expanded panel in the public petition against punitive home demolitions: Court President Naor ruled that “this petition, at the time it was filed, was not the optimal vehicle for the applicants’ arguments…”" ["documentDate"]=> string(19) "2015-11-15 00:00:00" ["type_di_name"]=> string(7) "updates" } [2]=> array(5) { ["di_name"]=> string(13) "Documents2921" ["related_di_name"]=> string(13) "Documents2687" ["title"]=> string(143) "HCJFH 063/15 - HaMoked Center for the Defence of the Individual et al. v. Minister of Defense et al. Applicants' Request to Submit an Authority" ["documentDate"]=> string(19) "2015-05-11 00:00:00" ["type_di_name"]=> string(5) "03_17" } [3]=> array(5) { ["di_name"]=> string(13) "Documents2921" ["related_di_name"]=> string(13) "Documents2686" ["title"]=> string(75) "Re: HCJFH 360/15 – Petitioners’ Motion for Leave to Submit an Authority" ["documentDate"]=> string(19) "2015-05-10 00:00:00" ["type_di_name"]=> string(5) "03_23" } [4]=> array(5) { ["di_name"]=> string(13) "Documents2921" ["related_di_name"]=> string(13) "Documents2625" ["title"]=> string(116) "HCJFH 360/15 - HaMoked - Center for the Defence of the Individual et al.v. Minister of Defense Respondents' Response" ["documentDate"]=> string(19) "2015-02-12 00:00:00" ["type_di_name"]=> string(5) "03_23" } [5]=> array(5) { ["di_name"]=> string(13) "Documents2921" ["related_di_name"]=> string(13) "Documents2595" ["title"]=> string(121) "HCJFH 360/15 HaMoked - Center for the Defence of the Individual et al.v. Minister of Defense Request for Further Hearing " ["documentDate"]=> string(19) "2015-01-15 00:00:00" ["type_di_name"]=> string(5) "03_17" } [6]=> array(5) { ["di_name"]=> string(13) "Documents2921" ["related_di_name"]=> string(11) "Updates1429" ["title"]=> string(248) "The court denied the general petition filed by HaMoked and other human rights organizations against the punitive house demolition policy: the court ruled that the state had the authority to demolish houses, but it should exercise it proportionately" ["documentDate"]=> string(19) "2015-01-01 00:00:00" ["type_di_name"]=> string(7) "updates" } }
Re: HCJFH 360/15 – Petitioners’ Motion for Leave to Submit an Authority
10.05.2015 | תגובה
Read more
array(7) { [0]=> array(5) { ["di_name"]=> string(13) "Documents2921" ["related_di_name"]=> string(11) "Updates1639" ["title"]=> string(247) "The HCJ approves the punitive demolition of two homes in Jabal al Mukabber: in the dissenting opinion, Justice Mazuz held that “a sanction which directs itself at harming the innocent cannot, in my opinion, be justified under any circumstance”" ["documentDate"]=> string(19) "2015-12-23 00:00:00" ["type_di_name"]=> string(7) "updates" } [1]=> array(5) { ["di_name"]=> string(13) "Documents2921" ["related_di_name"]=> string(11) "Updates1608" ["title"]=> string(273) "The HCJ dismissed the motion for further hearing before an expanded panel in the public petition against punitive home demolitions: Court President Naor ruled that “this petition, at the time it was filed, was not the optimal vehicle for the applicants’ arguments…”" ["documentDate"]=> string(19) "2015-11-15 00:00:00" ["type_di_name"]=> string(7) "updates" } [2]=> array(5) { ["di_name"]=> string(13) "Documents2921" ["related_di_name"]=> string(13) "Documents2687" ["title"]=> string(143) "HCJFH 063/15 - HaMoked Center for the Defence of the Individual et al. v. Minister of Defense et al. Applicants' Request to Submit an Authority" ["documentDate"]=> string(19) "2015-05-11 00:00:00" ["type_di_name"]=> string(5) "03_17" } [3]=> array(5) { ["di_name"]=> string(13) "Documents2921" ["related_di_name"]=> string(13) "Documents2686" ["title"]=> string(75) "Re: HCJFH 360/15 – Petitioners’ Motion for Leave to Submit an Authority" ["documentDate"]=> string(19) "2015-05-10 00:00:00" ["type_di_name"]=> string(5) "03_23" } [4]=> array(5) { ["di_name"]=> string(13) "Documents2921" ["related_di_name"]=> string(13) "Documents2625" ["title"]=> string(116) "HCJFH 360/15 - HaMoked - Center for the Defence of the Individual et al.v. Minister of Defense Respondents' Response" ["documentDate"]=> string(19) "2015-02-12 00:00:00" ["type_di_name"]=> string(5) "03_23" } [5]=> array(5) { ["di_name"]=> string(13) "Documents2921" ["related_di_name"]=> string(13) "Documents2595" ["title"]=> string(121) "HCJFH 360/15 HaMoked - Center for the Defence of the Individual et al.v. Minister of Defense Request for Further Hearing " ["documentDate"]=> string(19) "2015-01-15 00:00:00" ["type_di_name"]=> string(5) "03_17" } [6]=> array(5) { ["di_name"]=> string(13) "Documents2921" ["related_di_name"]=> string(11) "Updates1429" ["title"]=> string(248) "The court denied the general petition filed by HaMoked and other human rights organizations against the punitive house demolition policy: the court ruled that the state had the authority to demolish houses, but it should exercise it proportionately" ["documentDate"]=> string(19) "2015-01-01 00:00:00" ["type_di_name"]=> string(7) "updates" } }
HCJFH 360/15 - HaMoked - Center for the Defence of the Individual et al.v. Minister of Defense Respondents' Response
12.02.2015 | תגובה
Read more
array(7) { [0]=> array(5) { ["di_name"]=> string(13) "Documents2921" ["related_di_name"]=> string(11) "Updates1639" ["title"]=> string(247) "The HCJ approves the punitive demolition of two homes in Jabal al Mukabber: in the dissenting opinion, Justice Mazuz held that “a sanction which directs itself at harming the innocent cannot, in my opinion, be justified under any circumstance”" ["documentDate"]=> string(19) "2015-12-23 00:00:00" ["type_di_name"]=> string(7) "updates" } [1]=> array(5) { ["di_name"]=> string(13) "Documents2921" ["related_di_name"]=> string(11) "Updates1608" ["title"]=> string(273) "The HCJ dismissed the motion for further hearing before an expanded panel in the public petition against punitive home demolitions: Court President Naor ruled that “this petition, at the time it was filed, was not the optimal vehicle for the applicants’ arguments…”" ["documentDate"]=> string(19) "2015-11-15 00:00:00" ["type_di_name"]=> string(7) "updates" } [2]=> array(5) { ["di_name"]=> string(13) "Documents2921" ["related_di_name"]=> string(13) "Documents2687" ["title"]=> string(143) "HCJFH 063/15 - HaMoked Center for the Defence of the Individual et al. v. Minister of Defense et al. Applicants' Request to Submit an Authority" ["documentDate"]=> string(19) "2015-05-11 00:00:00" ["type_di_name"]=> string(5) "03_17" } [3]=> array(5) { ["di_name"]=> string(13) "Documents2921" ["related_di_name"]=> string(13) "Documents2686" ["title"]=> string(75) "Re: HCJFH 360/15 – Petitioners’ Motion for Leave to Submit an Authority" ["documentDate"]=> string(19) "2015-05-10 00:00:00" ["type_di_name"]=> string(5) "03_23" } [4]=> array(5) { ["di_name"]=> string(13) "Documents2921" ["related_di_name"]=> string(13) "Documents2625" ["title"]=> string(116) "HCJFH 360/15 - HaMoked - Center for the Defence of the Individual et al.v. Minister of Defense Respondents' Response" ["documentDate"]=> string(19) "2015-02-12 00:00:00" ["type_di_name"]=> string(5) "03_23" } [5]=> array(5) { ["di_name"]=> string(13) "Documents2921" ["related_di_name"]=> string(13) "Documents2595" ["title"]=> string(121) "HCJFH 360/15 HaMoked - Center for the Defence of the Individual et al.v. Minister of Defense Request for Further Hearing " ["documentDate"]=> string(19) "2015-01-15 00:00:00" ["type_di_name"]=> string(5) "03_17" } [6]=> array(5) { ["di_name"]=> string(13) "Documents2921" ["related_di_name"]=> string(11) "Updates1429" ["title"]=> string(248) "The court denied the general petition filed by HaMoked and other human rights organizations against the punitive house demolition policy: the court ruled that the state had the authority to demolish houses, but it should exercise it proportionately" ["documentDate"]=> string(19) "2015-01-01 00:00:00" ["type_di_name"]=> string(7) "updates" } }
HCJFH 360/15 HaMoked - Center for the Defence of the Individual et al.v. Minister of Defense Request for Further Hearing
15.01.2015 | בקשה
Read more
array(7) { [0]=> array(5) { ["di_name"]=> string(13) "Documents2921" ["related_di_name"]=> string(11) "Updates1639" ["title"]=> string(247) "The HCJ approves the punitive demolition of two homes in Jabal al Mukabber: in the dissenting opinion, Justice Mazuz held that “a sanction which directs itself at harming the innocent cannot, in my opinion, be justified under any circumstance”" ["documentDate"]=> string(19) "2015-12-23 00:00:00" ["type_di_name"]=> string(7) "updates" } [1]=> array(5) { ["di_name"]=> string(13) "Documents2921" ["related_di_name"]=> string(11) "Updates1608" ["title"]=> string(273) "The HCJ dismissed the motion for further hearing before an expanded panel in the public petition against punitive home demolitions: Court President Naor ruled that “this petition, at the time it was filed, was not the optimal vehicle for the applicants’ arguments…”" ["documentDate"]=> string(19) "2015-11-15 00:00:00" ["type_di_name"]=> string(7) "updates" } [2]=> array(5) { ["di_name"]=> string(13) "Documents2921" ["related_di_name"]=> string(13) "Documents2687" ["title"]=> string(143) "HCJFH 063/15 - HaMoked Center for the Defence of the Individual et al. v. Minister of Defense et al. Applicants' Request to Submit an Authority" ["documentDate"]=> string(19) "2015-05-11 00:00:00" ["type_di_name"]=> string(5) "03_17" } [3]=> array(5) { ["di_name"]=> string(13) "Documents2921" ["related_di_name"]=> string(13) "Documents2686" ["title"]=> string(75) "Re: HCJFH 360/15 – Petitioners’ Motion for Leave to Submit an Authority" ["documentDate"]=> string(19) "2015-05-10 00:00:00" ["type_di_name"]=> string(5) "03_23" } [4]=> array(5) { ["di_name"]=> string(13) "Documents2921" ["related_di_name"]=> string(13) "Documents2625" ["title"]=> string(116) "HCJFH 360/15 - HaMoked - Center for the Defence of the Individual et al.v. Minister of Defense Respondents' Response" ["documentDate"]=> string(19) "2015-02-12 00:00:00" ["type_di_name"]=> string(5) "03_23" } [5]=> array(5) { ["di_name"]=> string(13) "Documents2921" ["related_di_name"]=> string(13) "Documents2595" ["title"]=> string(121) "HCJFH 360/15 HaMoked - Center for the Defence of the Individual et al.v. Minister of Defense Request for Further Hearing " ["documentDate"]=> string(19) "2015-01-15 00:00:00" ["type_di_name"]=> string(5) "03_17" } [6]=> array(5) { ["di_name"]=> string(13) "Documents2921" ["related_di_name"]=> string(11) "Updates1429" ["title"]=> string(248) "The court denied the general petition filed by HaMoked and other human rights organizations against the punitive house demolition policy: the court ruled that the state had the authority to demolish houses, but it should exercise it proportionately" ["documentDate"]=> string(19) "2015-01-01 00:00:00" ["type_di_name"]=> string(7) "updates" } }